Now this is going to get interesting=) What it comes down to is operational temperatures of 2-stroke engines on land vs. marine cooled engines. This would explain why we mix 8oz to 1gal of gas. Land use you want to use the appropriate oil for air cooled and the appropriate oil for liquid cooled. In marine use the water is an uncontrolled temperature (no thermostat for our boat engines) and therefore has a cooler operational temperature requiring the appropriate oil for marine/outboard use. This is where the viscosity index comes into play as well as the TC-W3 certification.
Viscosity Index:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viscosity_index
Amsoil Saber Synthetic Outboard (water cooled) oil has a viscosity index of 141 and the professional Synthetic (air cooled) has a viscosity index of 136. Neiter of which have a TC-W3 certification (Two Cycle Watercooled).
www.amsoil.com/StoreFront/ato.aspx
Amsoil Synthetic Outboard
www.amsoil.com/StoreFront/atp.aspx
Amsoil Professional Synthetic
Honda HP2 offers very little info and from their product and is primarily used for the dirtbike line, water cooled land use, higher operational temperatures. Honda doesn't make oil, Mobile apparently makes most of Honda's lubricants. I can't find any HP2 test or spec data. Not for marine use 2-stroke engines.
www.honda.ca/MCPE/Motorcycle/A...lsAndLubricants
Castrol A747 is a high performance 2-stroke oil for road racing machines. It has a viscosity index of 123 which to me is good for high operational temperatures. I would not recommend this product for use on marine water cooled engines.
www.rgracing.co.uk/TDS/A%20747.pdf
Klotz Red R50 data sheet really shows the importance of mix regarding engine usage. The only one that specifies use for RC engines but for what area of useage? Given the mix air cooled use I think.
www.klotzlube.com/techsheet.asp?ID=48
Here's a list of all TC-W3 certified oil
www.nmma.org/certification/pro....asp?y=TCW32008
Personally I would opt to use a marine based lubricant over a land based lubricant especialy one with test results that exceed manufactures spec by Mercury Marine and others.
All in all, is it a synthetic oil? Can you mix it 8oz to 1gal? Does it do the job?